The Criminal Case Process
Below is a brief summary of the process in both misdemeanor and felony criminal cases in San Diego County.
Misdemeanor Cases

THE ARREST
First, an arrest is made. Often times in a misdemeanor case, the Defendant is not taken to jail, but rather given a citation and makes a promise to appear at an Arraignment within the next 30 days or so. If the police take the defendant to jail, three things can happen
- The defendant is released with no charges filed;
- The defendant posts bail/bond or is released on his or her own recognizance ("O.R.") and is scheduled for an arraignment; or
- The defendant remains in the custody and is transported to court for arraignment.
THE ARRAIGNMENT
The Defendant’s first appearance in court is the Arraignment. The following events occur at an Arraignment:
- The defendant is informed of the charges against him or her;
- The defendant is advised of his or her constitutional rights;
- If the defendant cannot afford an attorney of his or her own choice, an attorney is appointed by the court;
- The defendant enters a plea of guilty, not guilty or no contest.
- The defendant is released on his or her "Own Recognizance," or the court sets bail and the defendant is remanded/committed to the custody of the Sheriff.
Also at the arraignment, the Defense attorney may move for a Demurrer, or dismissal of the Complaint under Penal Code §1004, if the Complaint either (1) Fails to meet the specificity requirement adequately putting the Defendant on notice of the charges filed; (2) If the Complaint is filed in the wrong Court and that Court does not have Jurisdiction over the Defendant; (3) Due to Misjoinder; (4) If the Complaint fails to state a Public Offense; and (5) If there is a legal excuse or bar to the particular prosecution.
INVESTIGATION
After the Arraignment, the Criminal Defense Attorney begins an independent investigation into the alleged offense. This includes, among other things, visiting the scene of the alleged crime, interviewing witnesses to the alleged crime, interviewing and investigating the accuser, interviewing the family and friends of the Defendant, and sending any necessary evidence to scientific and/or psychological experts.
THE PRE-TRIAL HEARING OR READINESS CONFERENCE
At the pretrial hearing, there is an exchange of information between the prosecution and the defense known as discovery. Pretrial motions may also be filed before the start of the trial. Motions may be made to set aside the complaint, to dismiss the case, to suppress evidence, etc. The defendant may at this point change his or her plea to guilty or no contest.
PRE-TRIAL MOTIONS AND MOTIONS IN LIMINE
Prior to trial, the defense attorney may file any relevant pre-trial motions that will effect the outcome of the case. Examples of common pre-trial motions include, but are not limited to: Motion to Suppress Evidence Unlawfully Seized; Motion to Compel Additional Discovery from the Prosecutor; A “Pitchess Motion” to review the personnel file of any police officers involved in the arrest; A Motion Forcing the Prosecution to Disclose the Name of their Confidential Informant; A Motion to Dismiss for Governmental, Police, and/or Prosecutorial Misconduct; A Motion to Suppress a Confession; A Motion to Suppress an Eyewitness Identification; A Motion to Exclude Evidence of Rape/Trauma Syndrome; and A Motion to Include Evidence of the Accuser’s Prior Sexual Conduct in a Rape Case, among many other possible motions.
JURY TRIAL
Before a trial can begin, a jury must be selected. During the trial, witnesses may testify and evidence will be presented. At the conclusion of the trial, the jury must decide if the defendant is guilty or not guilty. If the jury finds the defendant is not guilty, he or she is released and cannot be tried again for the same crime. If the defendant is found guilty, the case will be continued for sentencing, or the defendant may be sentenced immediately. The defendant may appeal a conviction to the Appellate Department of the Superior Court.
COURT TRIAL
In lieu of a jury trial, the parties may agree to proceed with a court trial, in which the judge hears the evidence and arguments and finds the defendant guilty or not guilty.
Felony Cases

Felony crimes are punishable by a sentence to state prison term of more than one year or death. Some examples of felony crimes are murder, possession of dangerous drugs for sale, robbery and rape.
THE ARREST
First, an arrest is made. On a felony arrest the police take the defendant to jail. Three things can happen:
- The defendant is released - no charges are filed;
- The defendant posts bail/bond or is released on his/her own recognizance ("O.R.") and is scheduled for arraignment;
- The defendant remains in the custody of the law enforcement agency and is transported to court for arraignment.
CHARGING DOCUMENT
It is possible, in a felony case, that the charges were brought against the Defendant after a Grand Jury investigation which led to a Grand Jury Indictment. If this is the case, a warrant will likely be put out for the Defendant’s arrest, and then the Defendant will be arraigned after arrest. However, in most cases, the Defendant is arrested and then arraigned on the complaint.
THE ARRAIGNMENT
A felony arraignment on the complaint is the defendant's first court appearance. The following events occur:
- The defendant is informed of the charges against him or her;
- The defendant is advised of his or her constitutional rights;
- If the defendant cannot afford an attorney of his or her own choice, an attorney is appointed by the court;
- The defendant enters a plea;
- The court sets bail and the defendant is remanded to custody, or the defendant is released on his or her "Own Recognizance" or "O.R."
Also at the arraignment, the Defense attorney may move for a Demurrer, or dismissal of the Complaint under Penal Code §1004, if the Complaint either (1) Fails to meet the specificity requirement adequately putting the Defendant on notice of the charges filed; (2) If the Complaint is filed in the wrong Court and that Court does not have Jurisdiction over the Defendant; (3) Due to Misjoinder; (4) If the Complaint fails to state a Public Offense; and (5) If there is a legal excuse or bar to the particular prosecution.
THE PRELIMINARY HEARING
In felony cases, a preliminary hearing is held to determine if there is sufficient evidence for the judge to reasonably infer that a crime has been committed and that the defendant committed the crime and should therefore be "held over" for trial.
If the case was filed by complaint, then once a defendant is "held to answer," the prosecuting agency files a document called the Information. The defendant will subsequently be arraigned on the Information at which time he or she will enter a plea and proceed to trial.
INVESTIGATION
After the Arraignment, the Criminal Defense Attorney begins an independent investigation into the alleged offense. This includes, among other things, visiting the scene of the alleged crime, interviewing witnesses to the alleged crime, interviewing and investigating the accuser, interviewing the family and friends of the Defendant, and sending any necessary evidence to scientific and/or psychological experts.
PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE OR FELONY READINESS CONFERENCE
At the felony readiness conference, there is an exchange of information between the prosecution and the defense. Pretrial motions may also be filed before the start of the trial. Motions may be made to set aside the complaint, to dismiss the case, to suppress evidence, etc. The defendant may at this point change his or her plea to guilty or no contest. The Prosecutor and defense attorney also discuss any possible settlements to the case.
PRE-TRIAL MOTIONS AND MOTIONS IN LIMINE
Prior to trial, the defense attorney may file any relevant pre-trial motions that will effect the outcome of the case. Examples of common pre-trial motions include, but are not limited to: Motion to Suppress Evidence Unlawfully Seized; Motion to Compel Additional Discovery from the Prosecutor; A “Pitchess Motion” to review the personnel file of any police officers involved in the arrest; A Motion Forcing the Prosecution to Disclose the Name of their Confidential Informant; A Motion to Dismiss for Governmental, Police, and/or Prosecutorial Misconduct; A Motion to Suppress a Confession; A Motion to Suppress an Eyewitness Identification; A Motion to Exclude Evidence of Rape/Trauma Syndrome; and A Motion to Include Evidence of the Accuser’s Prior Sexual Conduct in a Rape Case, among many other possible motions.
JURY TRIAL
Before a trial can begin, a jury must be selected. During the trial, witnesses may testify and evidence will be presented. At the conclusion of the trial, the jury must decide if the defendant is guilty or not guilty. If the jury finds the defendant is not guilty, he or she is released and cannot be tried again for the same crime. If the defendant is found guilty, the case will be continued for sentencing, or the defendant may be sentenced immediately. The defendant may appeal a conviction to the Court of Appeal of the State
of California.
COURT TRIAL
In lieu of a jury trial, the defendant may agree to proceed with a court trial, in which the judge hears the evidence and arguments and finds the defendant guilty or not guilty. This is usually a good strategy if the only issue is an issue at law which the jury may not understand or may want to ignore for other reasons.
Do you have questions or do you want to make an appointment?
Call us at 858 444-5256 or use our contact form.
LAW OFFICE OF BRIAN R. MASON, APC
